« A Book in Hand Is Worth Two in the Bush
Main
Scientists Discover Frauds by Professor Reiner Protsch von Zieten »
February 19, 2005
Truth and Half Truth in Campaigning
The campaign for Mayor of the City of Los Angeles is on and weird things are following it. I don't live in Los Angeles but it is by far the largest nearby city. For that reason, I have an interest in how things go in the city. Two political advertising campaigns are underway that try to tie the City of Los Angeles and the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) together in a deceptive way. I take them up in no particular order.
The first is from a group called The Small Schools Alliance (SSA). It is presenting a very professional TV campaign featuring several school children pretending to run for mayor. The kids ask why none of the mayoral candidates talks about small schools.
One kid, Anna, says,"I'm running because the other candidates aren't talking about what really needs to be done to fix our schools."
Another, Harrison says,
"Why aren't the politicians talking about us?"
Another campaign trying to leverage issues involving the LAUSD is mayoral candidate Bob Hertzberg. After telling us that LA needs a mayor that doesn't tiptoe around issues, Hertzberg begins one of his forceful TV ads with the following two lines,
First, the LA Unified School District is a failure. I'll break it up into smaller districts.
The graphic proclaims, "Breakup the LA Unified School District." He tells this before he talks about road construction and traffic lights. Wow, if elected, Hertzberg will to break up the LA unified School District as his first priority.
Well, he won't. The problem with these two ads is that they rest on a serious equivocation. The mayor of LA has no power over the LAUSD. They are separate jurisdictions, separate legal entities, have separate elected governing bodies and they don't even cover the same geographical area. At best, the mayor has bully pulpit rights with regard to the school district but nothing more. Hertzberg admits this on his web site but TV, not a mock interview on a web site, makes the major impression on voters.
I am not claiming that Hertzberg and SSA have anything to do with each other. By my reading, they want to do quite different things. I am saying that they are both using a deceptive ploy to attract attention to their own cause. And we have had more than enough of this kind of deception. A deception where one says something loudly and takes it back softly. For this reason, I don't trust Hertzberg or the SSA and if I lived in LA, I would vote against them or their cause for fear that they real goals had nothing to do with their stated goals.
Posted by DuaneSmith at February 19, 2005 07:51 PM | Read more on Current Events |
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://WWW.telecomtally.com/cgi-bin/blog/mt-tb.cgi/26
Comments
Sorry, comments are closed for this post.
Send me an email if it is important.