June 19, 2012

Tropper and Vita On The Tiryns Alphabetic Inscription

Yesterday I mentioned that in addition to Dietrich and Loretz’ lengthy paper on the Tiryns alphabetic inscription in UF 42 Josef Tropper and Juan-Pablo Vita also have one on the same topic (“Die keilaplhabetische Inschrift aus Tiryns,” [(2010 published 2011)], 693-695). Tropper and Vita suggest three possible readings:

They cite Hebrew cognates for all there (four) lexemes.

Tropper and Vita prefer their third option, mš‘ l[ . . .]; maśśa‘- + l, and suggest two understandings.

While Tropper and Vita’s first suggestion, mš‘l[(t) . . .], "wish, desire,“ is in the same neighborhood as Dietrich and Loretz‘ suggestion, Tropper and Vita don’t develop it as full as do Dietrich and Loretz. The second understanding of their third option, while seemingly similar to Dietrich and Loretz' interpretation, is only superficially so.

Among the things that all this tells me is that there is still lots of room for alternative approaches. Neither set of scholars suggests that the inscription be read as a proper name (or fragment of a proper name). So, I think I’ll continue to think about this.

Posted by Duane Smith at June 19, 2012 12:52 PM | Read more on Ugarit |

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.telecomtally.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/4009

Comments

Post a comment

Please read Abnormal Interest's Comments Policy.

Name:

Email Address:

Your email address with not be posted.

URL:

Remember Me?


Comments:

The following HTML tags are allowed in comments:

and no others.

Tags: